Wednesday, November 28, 2007

Unspeakable Things

Well, I have to start with HAPPY THANKSGIVING!!! I hope you've all been able to take the time to scope out the picture albums. There are quite a few, and many laughable moments captured in pixels. Scroll down and follow the links to visual memories galore!!!! And a special thanks has to go to the many people, especially tita Cecile and the Demano family who made our Thanksgiving possible, and to those of you in the States who contributed recipes, prayers, and e-mails that kept us missing home and grateful for our country the whole way through. As it has been said, we have much to be THANKFUL FOR!!!!!! Next, I have to apologize for my blatant absence from our posts for a while. You no doubt noticed the huge gap which occurred in the weeks leading up to and recovering from the annual GK expo the last weekend in October. Again, there are a few pics in the album, and much to share about this intense gathering of GK workers, volunteers, supporters and partners, and new GK home-owners. Although it will probably never appear here, this was an incredible, challenging, frustrating and grace-loaded learning experience for all of us. Now, for my life (and silence): It has been our precedent and desire to share on this blog the many wonderful things that happen to us and around us in the Philippines, in the GK communities, and in our day-to-day interactions. Aware of our readership and trying to focus on the positive side of challenges, we often find ourselves posting only the good or weird experiences on our adventure. We all know, however, that life is no picnic, and no scar is earned without its wound. That is probably a very harsh way to say that many of the things we have learned and experienced first-hand have not been "good" in the general sense. We find ourselves often surrounded by disorganization, miscommunication, double standards, misunderstandings and confused visions. The challenge for us as Americans continues to be to accept a style of work and personal relations that is not found in the U.S. However, I believe the challenge for us as Christians is to ask - and strive to answer honestly- what is truly "being Spirit-led," vs. what is just laziness; and where is reality between the Western way, the GK way, the "right" way, the better way, and the successful way? I think for myself I have finally been led by grace to a place where I am not sure that a "Western way" would actually work here in the Philippines (a strange and twisted statement considering the countless ways in which Filipinos strive to be Western). I can look around me and see Western models crumbling with failures constantly. At the same time, I cannot say that I believe this Filipino model would work well in the U.S. Frankly, I don't think it would. The template for development by GK I believe is universally adaptable, yes, but the work method, standards, and other functional normalties would never be successful in the U.S. Some examples of these differences: 1) Western minds are typically trained to think in linear progressions, moving from A thru B to arrive at C. The Filipino mind (and I am told many Asian minds) tend to think in circles, flowing freely between A and C and B without strict adherence to order. 2) The "GK Way" has been expressed in not so clear terms as putting something on the ground first, testing it to see if it works, and then coming up with a plan later. In short, very little "planning ahead" is ever done, and many unnecessary steps and much waste in the result. 3) Filipinos, perhaps influenced by centuries of landlessness, poverty, and living in survival mode, tend not to think beyond themselves, or beyond their immediate situation. This reality manifests itself in little things like buying soap only to do one load of laundry or buying cell phone load (usage) that is only good for one day. It also expresses itself in larger things like setting up office methods that only serve the current situation without planning for growth and expansion that is already happening, or tearing down all of the vegetation in a place in bringing in landfill to build houses without looking ahead to the immediate need for utilizing those same natural resources (low ground for water drainage, vegetation for shade, waste materials for fertilizer, etc.). Lastly, and probably most painfully, is the expression of this mindset in interpersonal interactions. This is the one I find most odd, and is probably the one that comes with the most excuses. I will allow that it probably comes from the fact that most people are used to fending for themselves. I am struck by the number of times I have been in a Jeepnee and people refuse to slide toward the driver to make it easier for others to get in, or when a person gets out, to slide over enough for everyone else squished on the bench to be a bit more comfortable. I have been cut in line countless times, I think because I wasn't standing with my chest pressed against the counter to indicate to the person behind me that I am next. I have been blatantly ignored even by the very people that I live with, and sometimes by the people that I work with. These realities are hard, often discouraging, and force me to question the depth and breadth of our Christian expression. I have worked in several ministries before and know well that the hardest part about working for any Christian organization is working with human beings- that's right folks who make mistakes and are imperfect. But I am surprised, sometimes shocked, and often hurt that this is the reality from a culture that prides itself on being so openly hospitable, truly joy-filled, and desiring to be generous. Yes, the people by whom we have been hosted are tremendous and their generosity towards us is endless and flowing. But as a culture, I find most people here, including myself and my American friends, becoming more selfish, self-centered, and blind to others than I ever experienced in the U.S. It is hard to write this because I know the number of people- people I consider friends- who will be hurt if they read this. But I also believe in the high value of honesty and openness in struggle. I have fallen in love with many Filipinos. I hope to shed light in this area so that they may strive to challenge each other to more embracing of all life around them. To see the connection between pollution and health, between education and respect, between environment and life, between love and freedom. The work of GK is often challenging, at times disappointing, and usually good. But in the ocean of "culture" in which we swim, it often feels as though a small stone has been dropped into rough and troublesome waters, and the ripples are dispersed by the next breaking wave. (as usually happens at these moments, God has just given us another blessing and I must attend to it. He has not abandoned us - I have never felt that way here. But I cannot being to understand the things he is teaching us here- humility is first among these). Thank you for your love and your prayers. Please keep them coming, and know that you are in ours. Happy Thanksgiving!

9 comments:

Fredy said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Fredy said...

Hello Patrick and All,

Thank you for your candor. Welcome to the third world with your first world mentality little brother. I believe you are now ready to do the work. The honeymoon is over and you have now been acclimated and can now see, actually see... But just like a marriage - a lifelong journey of two individuals staying true to themselves, yet traveling as one, together - your GK journey is the same in many ways. You bring your first world mentality and knowhow, share it us, your third world brethren, without compromising your values or trying to change our culture. No compromises, just melding and working as one.

Stand in line like you belong there and don't let anyone cut in front of you. Act like a local. Think like a local.

When I was in the Navy (US), we'd get briefings before we hit a foreign port - customs, culture, do's and don't's, etc. Coming from a third world point-of-view, I'd tell my shipmates and friends, those who work with me and under me, specially the young ones who's never been anywhere outside of the US, not to be frustrated just because the people are different, don't speak english, etc. They are no less weirder, dumber, stranger, or less knowledgeable than you are, just different. You, are the visitor and not the other way around. In Hong Kong and Japan, you'll never get across the street or on the train if every time you bump someone, you take the time to say "pardon me" or "excuse me". Welcome to the third world little brother. In Manila, the most dangerous drivers are those who've ever driven there before - the tourists, the foreigner. Does all this make sense?

Part of our challenge here in the US also (with partners and volunteers) is trying to bridge the gap of time lines and time zones. Our drive-thru mindset of quick and efficient does not apply there. Rebuilding a country and a people is not a small undertaking.

Be patient little brother. Share what you know, what you can, where you can - not to change but to make better. "We are workers, not master builders, ministers, not messiahs. We are prophets of a future not our own." - Oscar Romero

GK is very fluid. We are all learning together along the way.

God bless,
kuya Fredy

Unknown said...

Don't expect the Philippines to adjust to your standards brother. And let me just stress this out to you, we are not trying to be Western here. Stop over analyzing things and generalizing based on isolated cases. You have so much to learn on the ground and I think you have failed to put both your feet on the ground. Humility and understanding are virtues a true Christian should have. In coming here, you should learn to unlearn what you know and learn to open your eyes to the reality we are facing here.

Patrick said...

Ivan - I have to say that I have never expected the Philippines to adjust, or even accommodate my standards. My purpose in sharing this post is to share honestly the things which I struggle with. Perhaps it is not well stated, but I have tried to say that both cultures need to learn to respect one another and expressly NOT to claim or to strive to be something which they are not. My eyes are open, and it is as a Christian that I can openly share this struggle, knowing my own need for growth, humility, and forgiveness.

Dianne said...

Peace Patrick. As much frustrations and challenges that I have faced in GKBC, there have been even more rewards that are priceless. I have realized this more now that I am away. There are things that can definately be improved in GK, but I believe they are working on it, especially with the fieldbook. We just happened to come first and at a time of much turmoil with the CFC/GK split. AND your prob at that stage of 'the peak' of your frustration (lol). You still have time left there that can prove to be a turning point for you. Use the frustration as lessons to grow from as best as you can. I do understand some of your frustrations and its good to get them out... but be patient. GK is the best thing I ever did and I will be eternally grateful for it. You are all in my prayers... Love & GOD BLESS, Dianne

Patrick said...

Dianne- Thanks for your thoughts and your prayers. Fortunately, I think I am passed my "peak" of frustrations, as you call it. I wholly agree that there is much more to be celebrated, and it is with time, reflection, and deeper joy from these experiences that I have the freedom to reflect on the hard times of our journey and to share those- hopefully with honesty about about myself and my experiences. Know that we miss you here and the many gifts you share. Enjoy your Christmas with your fam, and have fun in HAWAII!!!

Mon said...

Dear Patrick,

You speak of honestly sharing the things which you struggle with, let me then do you the courtesy of speaking plainly in response.

You struggle in many ways with the way many things are done in the Philippines. I advise you to allow the possibility that, perhaps,not everything you know, today, is the best of means, methods, culture, or technology. An open mind will often open your eyes to a whole new world kept shut by ignorance, intolerance, arrogance, or insensitivity.

Consider the mother that buys soap only to do one load of laundry may have just that amount of money left over from the day's income (often barely enough to feed her family). To her, tomorrow, the family may forego doing the laundry for want of a second meal for the day. How many times have you been to a GK site? Would you not have seen this if your eyes were truly open? Would it be easier for you to simply dismiss her own struggles as a result of such practices?

You speak of the frustration over jeepney passengers who refuse to slide over toward the driver to make it easier for you to get in. You are at the beginning of your journey while they are nearing their stop. As they get off, each in his own turn, you will eventually slide closest to the door to ease your way in getting off. Were you, understandably as a newbie jeepney passenger, being arrogant in wanting to sit nearest the doorway instead of making your way to the innermost seats?

The ability to think in terms outside a linear method allows for many fruits in itself. Did you care to celebrate your colleagues instead for their flexibility, agility, or creativity?

In response to Ivan, here you say that you never expected the Philippines to adjust, or even accommodate your standards. I will allow that, as a Christian, you may not have been aware that you were doing so.

The work is worthy but the way it is done is just as important as the results. That is the way of God's world. How do you touch the lives of those you seek to serve? How do you make them feel by your presence?

As I read the posts of your colleagues, I do not have the impression that theirs are attended by the same angst or bitterness that I find in your words. I, therefore, feel that your words come from someplace else. Perhaps something you may have had difficulty confronting but, I suspect, you may have been aware of for sometime. Could this then be the reason you were brought here? Consider this...

My prayer for you is peace of heart.

Dianne said...

Thanks Patrick! Well I'm glad you are past your 'peak of frustration' lol congratulations!
Peace 2 you.
There are so many wonderful gifts within GK its amazing. I think Mon's comment (above) is a really good perspective and provides much insight for reflection and growth. And in all fairness to you, thanks for your honesty. Its good that people know things are not all rosey in the process of GK, especially for ambitious long-term foreigners.. that are not just there for a month. It's sometimes difficult to process. But in hindsight, thats so great! because it makes the journey REAL. That the Philippines is a 'third world' country and to help solve this at the level GK is striving for isn't an easy mountain to climb. (And yet thru God & a movement like GK all things are possible.) And the time we entered is significant. It is a real commitment that will take many generations. We are blessed to be a part of it's history and it's growing pains, and help where we can. There is much to celebrate in that. And we have made alot of really valuable relationships and friends within GK that are family. I think we're always hardest on the ones we love most... There is a home and valuable work in GK that we are always welcome to (hopefully. lol) Peace 2 you, Dianne

Unknown said...

Patrick,

I know what you were trying to say and you just want to be honest. Rest assured that everyone respects how you feel. My only contention was you chose the wrong venue to voice out what you feel. You should have gone straight to those people whom you think needs to hear how you feel. And understand how everyone reacted to your honesty. If it is your right to voice out what you feel, then it is our right to react this way. I respect and honor your courage in voicing out your sentiments. But again, there is a right venue for that. I respect you honesty. But you have to practice to honor people in private and correct them in private, which is the practice in GK and CFC.

Honestly, I cannot fully blame you for your sentiments. I was worse when I was still a mission volunteer for YFC Philippines. I was so critical about the structure of the organization and how it was managed. I always engaged in debates with my superiors. These made me decide to leave the work and just pursue my studies. Eventually, I realized that criticisms when not properly channeled will all be useless. This consequently gave me a hard time reconnecting to myself to the service I once loved. But I was fortunate enough that this community knows how to forgive a black sheep like me.

If you think you have to defend yourself, clarify something or you think I misunderstood your points, feel free to approach me. I will be open to any dialogue. God bless.


Ivan Angelo Quiwa